Skip to content

Maine Catholics Alienated

September 30, 2009

According to a letter to the editor in today’s Portland Press Herald, Bishop Malone has released a video homily to be played in every Catholic Church in the state of Maine arguing for Question 1 (and against marriage equality).  His instructions are that every church should play this video last Sunday.  After taking collections for the Yes on 1 campaign in church, there seems to be no line he is unwilling to cross.  The letter to the editor (below) really gets at the position in which Catholics who disagree find themselves.

Update: Louise at Pam’s Houseblend and Joe at AMERICAblog sent along the video:

This is beyond appalling.  No one is making the Catholic church perform same sex marriages–just saying they can’t impose this belief on everyone else.

If anyone has this video, please send it my way.

I am deeply offended by Bishop Richard Malone’s intrusion into every Catholic Mass offered on a recent Sunday throughout the state of Maine by requiring that a videotape of a “homily” be shown on that date (or a later one).

This was not be a homily; it was another part of the bishop’s campaign to persuade Catholics to vote to overturn the recently passed law that would end discrimination against same-sex couples.

To my knowledge, Bishop Malone has never visited my parish, let alone offered a homily.

I belong to one of Maine’s most diverse (in every way you’d like to define that term) Catholic parishes; a parish where there is a wide range of cultures, languages, and viewpoints, but where we all come together in love and mutual respect to worship every Sunday.

This is a parish where members are actively engaged in various aspects of community life outside of the church as well. It is a parish that embraces and celebrates the richness in diversity.

This intrusion leaves me and other Catholics who have very real disagreements with the bishop’s position (many Catholics believe that all discrimination is injustice), and with his making the same-sex marriage issue a priority (of all the places the bishop could be investing his time, energy, and resources), with few options if we are to act as our consciences would dictate.

As a Catholic whose conscience directs me to resist the bishop’s campaign, my choices were to either not attend Mass on the Sunday that the video was shown, or to demonstrate my dissent in some way that would necessarily disrupt a time of prayer and communion (by walking out during the Mass, for example).

At a time when we need leadership that would unite, I continue to wonder why the bishop has chosen to divide us.

Why this issue (versus, say, a campaign to end poverty, to end violence in our homes and on our streets, to end exploitation of our environment, etc.), and why this campaign (versus some kind of dialogue that would hopefully lead to greater understanding and appreciation of our differences)?

Tony Scucci


h/t Debbie.

One Comment leave one →
  1. newz4i permalink
    November 6, 2009 8:26 pm

    Catholics: We Do Not Like Your Families Either.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: